Simple procedure that attaches a GCE persistent disk to a VM where the disk itself is encrypted by a key you define (Customer Supplied Encryption Key). In addition, the startup script also does a final round of encryption on top of that on the mounted disk using LUKS.
Essentially, you’re left with a disk that can only get decrypted if you have both encryption keys:
- CSEK key that must be proivded even to mount the disk
- LUKS key which decodes the data within the disk.
For example, the Disk is encrypted with CSEK:
$ gcloud compute disks describe csek-disk --zone us-central1-a
and a mounted volume thats also further encrypted using LUKS:
$ lsblk -f
NAME FSTYPE LABEL UUID MOUNTPOINT
└─sda1 ext4 384f1f4a-cc72-404c-91e4-9cd3ce2bf2c0 /
sdb crypto_LUKS c5b39010-de81-4cc2-aec4-4ca20e8ab915
└─vault_encrypted_volume ext4 5fb89e88-7a85-4f33-8a39-f52e048e416d /media/vaultfs
Both encryption keys can be stored anywhere but at a minimum, the LUKS key needs to be accessible from within the VM. The full flow outlined here:
- Generate LUKS and CSEK keys
- Upload keys to Google Secret Manager
- Create Disk with CESK enabled
- Create GCE Service Account the VM will run as
- Set IAM permissions:
- Grant GCE Service account access to both LUKS and CESK secrets
- Grant GCE Service account access to attach the CSEK enabled disk
6. Create the GCE instance and enable a startup script:
- Download both secrets from Google Secret Manager
- Attach the CSEK enabled disk to the VM using the secret
- Add LUKS encryption to the mounted disk using the secret
7. As the instance is getting created,
- Grant GCE Service account access to bind itself to the GCE instance
The procedure here runs a startup script which attaches the CSEK disk and mounts a LUKS volume. Its not necessary to ‘self-mount’ the disk itself but it is necessary to do the luks decryption on the VM itself.
Set environment variables and enable Secrets Manager. Secrets Manager will hold the luks and csek key and control it via IAM permissions. Access to the keys will be restricted to the VM itself that will mount the disks.
export PROJECT_ID=`gcloud config get-value core/project`export PROJECT_NUMBER=`gcloud projects describe $PROJECT_ID --format="value(projectNumber)"`export ZONE=us-central1-agcloud services enable secretmanager.googleapis.com
Create csek and luks secrets
export csek_key=`openssl rand 16 | xxd -p`
export luks_key=`openssl rand 16 | xxd -p`echo -n $csek_key | gcloud beta secrets create csek --replication-policy=automatic --data-file=-echo -n $luks_key | gcloud beta secrets create luks --replication-policy=automatic --data-file=-gcloud beta secrets versions access 1 --secret csek
gcloud beta secrets versions access 1 --secret luks
Create CSEK enabled disk
This step will set the CSEK encryption key to a disk
csek-disk-1. As mentioned anyone that even wants to mount a this disk to a VM must provide this key.
sec=`gcloud beta secrets versions access 1 --secret csek`
cat <<EOF > csek-key-file.json
"key": "`echo -n $sec | base64`",
EOFgcloud compute disks create csek-disk-1 \
--csek-key-file csek-key-file.json \
--size 10GB \
Create the GCE service Account
Create a dedicated, restricted service account that will access both keys.
gcloud iam service-accounts create gce-svc-account \
--display-name "GCE Service Account"gcloud iam service-accounts describe \
Set IAM permission on the service account
Set permissions for the GCE service accunt to the keys as well as allow the
$GCE_SERVICE_ACCOUNT to "self-mount" the CSEK disk at runtime.
As you will see in the startup script we will run, the VM in question will itself mount the CSEK encrypted disk. We do not need necessarily need to do that step by the VM and could have attached the disk to any VM administratively (remotely). The ability to attach the disk would require us to have access to the CSEK disk anyway.
gcloud compute disks add-iam-policy-binding csek-disk-1 \
--zone us-central1-a \
--role=roles/compute.instanceAdmin -qgcloud iam service-accounts add-iam-policy-binding \
--role=roles/iam.serviceAccountUsergcloud beta secrets add-iam-policy-binding \
csek --member=serviceAccount:$GCE_SERVICE_ACCOUNT \
--role=roles/secretmanager.secretAccessor -qgcloud beta secrets add-iam-policy-binding \
luks --member=serviceAccount:$GCE_SERVICE_ACCOUNT \
WARNING anyone which access to the service account or ssh access to the VM can ‘view’ both encryption keys. The idea is you would restrict access to both (or revoke IAM access the service account on the secrets once bootup is complete)
Create the GCE instance
As mentioned above, the startup script below ‘self mounts’ the CSEK disk. You can create the VM and mount the disk separately but to do that, you would need to supply the CSEK key. The startup script access the CSEK key and mounts the disk on its own.
gcloud compute instances create gce-csek \
--metadata-from-file startup-script=startup.sh \
--image-project=debian-cloud gcloud compute instances \
add-iam-policy-binding gce-csek \
The final step sets permissions on the VM to complete attaching the disk.
Note: The last step has a potential race condition since we need to provision a GCE instance to allow the service account to perform operations on it “by itself” (i.,e the service account is itself attaching the encrypted disk). The startup script attaches the disk which means the permission should propagate by then. You don’t ofcourse have to mount the CSEK disk inline on startup and are free to do omit that step.
gcloud beta secrets remove-iam-policy-binding csek --member=serviceAccount:$GCE_SERVICE_ACCOUNT --role=roles/secretmanager.secretAccessor -qgcloud beta secrets remove-iam-policy-binding luks --member=serviceAccount:$GCE_SERVICE_ACCOUNT --role=roles/secretmanager.secretAccessor -q
cryptsetup luksClose vault_encrypted_volume
gcloud compute instances detach-disk csek-disk-1 --disk vault-backend gcloud compute instances delete gce-csek -q
gcloud compute disks delete csek-disk-1 -q
gcloud alpha secrets delete luks -q
gcloud alpha secrets delete csek -q
Using alternative key distribution mechanisms instead of “gcloud secrets”
The example above used gcloud secrets engine as convenience but you are ofcourse free to distribute the encryption keys in anyway you see necessary. For example, the csek and luks keys can be manged via:
- HashiCorp Vault K/V Engine VM will authenticate to Vault and Vault returns both keys
- Google Cloud KMS Encrypt and Decrypt the keys with KMS.
- Trusted Platform Module in various ways: a. Embed a GCP ServiceAccount to a TPM and then with KMS via TPMTokenSource b. Encrypt the secret with the TPM’s ekPub and securely import or duplicate c. Embed the keys directly to the TPM and apply IMA policies on its access. Use the TPM to decrypt the secret d. Embed mTLS certificate to the TPM and use that to authenticate to Vault
The core issue in each is bootstrapping: how do you seed the VM to allow access to the keys used for LUKS and CSEK mounted disks. For Vault, the VM will need to authenticate to Vault to ge the keys. For KMS, the VM will need to authenticate and get authorized to access the KMS keys. For TPM, the VM will need to get seeded with the secret or securely transferred.
Ultimately, there are various ways to go about this depending on the complexity involved.